the wagon on the picture, was that a standard army issue or a product made behind the lines? I read somewhere that the Signal Corps of the British was set up in the 20's. If that's so, how were communications organised before, did every company had its own unit? And, as armies everywhere have the habit to give names and abbreviations to almost everything, was there a name for the guys responsible for the pidgeons, 'private pidgeoneer' or something? And was there some training?
Before the Royal Signals was formed, Signals were the duty of the Royal Engineers (Interestingly, the Royal Flying Corps started off as the Royal Engineers Air Battalion before 1912).
As for the names of the lowest rank, traditionally in the RE it is 'Sapper' instead of Private, although signals men may have been known as 'Signallers'. I've got a book on the work of the RE Signals Section in WW1 but have yet to start it.
The wheels on that wagon are very interesting, can't really tell if they're properly made disc wheels, or the traditional wheel with wooden spokes fitted with covers
The RE took over the pigeon service in December 1915 (from Intelligence) - RE History Part 14. There is a picture of a horse-drawn mobile loft on that page. There is a motorised one shown at Intrepid pigeoneers - this is also British - see also tankbook.co.uk - Divisional Signal Company Royal Engineers. There's more about pigeons there and, it seems from that, their RE handlers were "Signallers" - or, informally, "Pigeoneers" (which is seemingly not a US designation as I first thought).
-- Edited by Rectalgia on Thursday 18th of February 2010 06:06:21 PM
If you have a good google you'll find lots of stuff on the subject. There were amazing numbers in use - can't remember exactly, but several hundred. Horse-drawn models at first but vans, lorries, and, of course, buses were converted as the War went on. The French also converted buses but, oddly, I've never found any material on German use of pigeons. One assumes they used them.
Somewhere on the Forum are articles on converting the B-Type bus and a French toy bus (that was given away with breakfast cereal or somesuch) into pigeon lofts. A propos of which, one of the articles mentions that the author had to guess what the roof might have looked like. I've found a pic that shows one; the roof of the B-Type was probably similar. See below.
-- Edited by James H on Thursday 18th of February 2010 08:05:43 PM
"Sometimes things that are not true are included in Wikipedia. While at first glance that may appear like a very great problem for Wikipedia, in reality is it not. In fact, it's a good thing." - Wikipedia.
The pigeon service in WW1 is described in a book by Col Osman, "Pigeons in the Great War." published by the racing pigeon Publishing Company. The pigeon service was started by a man called Major Alec Whaley. He ttranferred from the Intelligence Corps to the new Royal Engineers Signals and became Staff Officer (Pigeons). He trained many of the pigeon handlers himself. The pigeons were obtained from English pigeon fanciers. (The only way to get rationed pigeon feed was to provide birds for the services.) There were static and mobile lofts. The first mobile lofts were built on horsedrawn wagons Mark VII. There is a plan at the Royal Corps of Signals Museum at Blandford of which I have a copy. Only six motor mobile lofts were built (Motor Mobile Lofts 1 to 6) on bus bodies. Most of these seem to be B-types but one photo is possibly a Daimler bus.
I simply didn't realise that pigeons were such a big item. Like many second line troops, like catering, transportation, offices, they not always have that spectacular look of the front line. Much surprised that there is so much information and even books about it! Many thanks for letting it know!
This is getting facinating the one thing that has struck is the colour schemes of the wagons,unlike the usual "drab" colours of army transport these are not at all.I would say they are extremly "eye catching".So does this mean they were a fair distance from the Front Lines (if not ideal for target practice!!) or is it a case that the pidgeons can spot them??? I must be honest with the havoc the little buggers made with my vegetable garden I am definitly not a great fan of these feathered vandals!!!!
If you had seen what they did to my prize broccoli you wouldn't make light of it. What was left went very nice with the pie. Pidgeon of course!!!!!!!!!!!!!
baldwin wrote:This is getting facinating the one thing that has struck is the colour schemes of the wagons,unlike the usual "drab" colours of army transport these are not at all.I would say they are extremly "eye catching".So does this mean they were a fair distance from the Front Lines (if not ideal for target practice!!) or is it a case that the pidgeons can spot them???
I should think the mobile lofts accompanied the headquarters units in their peregrinations. There is one depicted so in Australian service in Le Hamel - Tanks, pigeons and bullets 'by air'.
I have no idea what the colours accomplished but I think there is little doubt they were intended for the benefit of the birds. Mobile lofts are virtually an oxymoron, considering their usually static nature, perhaps it was considered the 'rats with wings' needed a little help with such an 'unnatural' arrangement. We need a pigeon fancier's input (did I say 'rats'? no, no I didn't mean that) - or some source documentation.
And reward. Reward is an important part of pigeon performance. Nothing like a nice bit of broccoli to make up for being buffeted, gassed, shot at, pursued by enemy raptors and inappropriately identified as comestibles by peckish people. All of this a generation before the institution of the Dickin Medal!
a picture of a Belgian pigeoneer, or "soldaat-duivenmelker". According to my information (but please correct me if I am wrong, members from Belgium?) every division had a mobile loft with ca. 100 birds. There was a central loft, Centrale Duiventil" with a reserve of 400 pigeons. There must be ven a monument in Brussels in memory of the pigeoneers killed in action.
looks like the pigeon in the missile cone hadn't much of a chance to survive it's mission. Bit like the German shepherd dogs with an anti tank mine on their backs, WW2, trained to crawl under a (Soviet far as I know) tank.
Brussel isn't the only place with a pigeon monument. Charlreroi has one, and at Fort Vaux is a small monument, with the text of commander Raynal on it, which he sent with his last pigeon before the fortress fall. The pigeon made it but the message wasn't answered. There is a nice site: pierreswesternfront.punt.nl, with pictures of the latter.
What on earth? Well, I suppose an enemy aviator passing by and short of ammunition might convince himself it was a mirage and leave it alone? But I suppose the main thing was that a loft indicated a headquarters nearby so unless it was a long way behind the lines it would indeed be a good idea to disguise it? I just don't know. It doesn't look very much camouflaged to me.
these pictures are from a magazine called The War Pictorial, by the Illustrated London News and Sketch LTD, 1918. I guess they published a Dutch/French edition for the Belgian market. The caption of the first picture says: Pilot sending a pigeon, the attachment of the message and a picture of a bird who saved 4 people. Picture two says: pigeon arriving on the loft, the plank is balanced in such a way that the bird is 'pushed' into the loft, the weight of the bird does ring a bell. These were navy birds, that's clear of course. I read that submarines too had pigeons on board.
from the same source: transportation of pigeons by motorcycles and pigeons in hospital. The caption(oval picture) says that these brave birds delivered their mail though they were wounded, and lost a leg. (It's not a "Bernard and Andre the Brave MG dogs story...) I am not a motor cycle expert, so I can't tell which bikes these were.
...I am not a motor cycle expert, so I can't tell which bikes these were.
I'm no expert either Kieffer but there are numerous point of similarity to a post-war BSA so I'm guessing in that direction.
Aaagh - in my searches I came across the half-track motor cycle Kleines Kettenkraftrad HK 101. Thank goodness that is WW2, we don't have to worry about it.
The motorcycles are Triumph model H's, superb machines, along with the Douglas 2 3/4hp's they were the main despatch rider motorcycles.
I'm currently reading a book on the Battle of Arras and it mentions that German pigeons often ended up in British lofts - easily distinguishable as they were dyed red!
I assume that the pigeon lofts were painted (as suggested above) in a colour scheme that the pigeons would recognise as opposed to a colour scheme for camouflage (which would mean that the pigeons couldnt find it). I understand that they were black and white. Can anybody confirm this?
this one is from a book called Der Erste Weltkrieg, Gerstenberg Verlag, Germany. I think it's some kind of school book, nicely documentated. I hope the 'Verlag' isn't angry with me, copying a picture of an apparantly espionage pigeon, dropped with a parachute above occupied territory.
Talking of spy pigeons, frame below from Wallace and Grommet's World of Invention, represented as an actual German photograph from WW1. Although there apparently was a German patent for a pigeon-borne camera the general consensus seems to be the photo shows mock-ups and the pic was for propaganda/spreading of fear uncertainty and doubt. Which is still interesting. Wallace and Grommet? I have to get out more.
Bizarre as it might sound its a real invention and actually worked but I dont think was used with spying in mind just a way of taking arial photos for amusement...
The parachute pidgeon is WW2 I do believe dropped by both Allied(espionage) and Axis(counter espionage) on france.... the german pidgeons usually had something like cigarettes with them, operatives were told to eat the birds and smoke the cigarettes...
The idea of a photographing pigeon seems to be a bit older, this one is from 1909. The para-pigeon picture, no I do think this is a ww1. Well, at least the book says... The 'smoke the cigarettes and eat the bird' thing, I think that's coming from something else, apparantly French counter espionage, or even from general De Gaulle himself.. gave that advise to French citizens finding any German pigeons in 1944. The Germans were using pigeons with misleading information, and to prove they were 'genuine' a box of real English cigarettes was attached. But I do not know if that's true, or just another myth.
-- Edited by kieffer on Thursday 24th of February 2011 08:10:03 AM
Well, I'm never going to rely on Wallace and Grommet for research again (well, maybe Grommet). The programme found the patent OK, even replicated/interpreted the camera and harness and fitted it to a pigeon (which promptly fell over). But no mention that it actually worked "back in the day", in fact concluded it couldn't have. Shame Wallace, shame.
tests are mentioned in the 1909 text, even successfully. May be the Wallace and Grommet camera was too heavy, the weight should have been no more than 75 gr... Herr Neubronner was a pharmacist, using pigeons to carry recipes and medicine. One of his pigeons stayed away rather long, Dr Neubronner got curious and wanted to know the whereabouts...
The idea of a photographing pigeon seems to be a bit older, this one is from 1909. The para-pigeon picture, no I do think this is a ww1. Well, at least the book says... The 'smoke the cigarettes and eat the bird' thing, I think that's coming from something else, apparantly French counter espionage, or even from general De Gaulle himself.. gave that advise to French citizens finding any German pigeons in 1944. The Germans were using pigeons with misleading information, and to prove they were 'genuine' a box of real English cigarettes was attached. But I do not know if that's true, or just another myth.
-- Edited by kieffer on Thursday 24th of February 2011 08:10:03 AM
There is a museum in Germany which has an exhibit of Dr Neubronners Pigeons I think this is where most of the pics of stuffed pigeons with camaras comes from, good find on the Camara patent rectaglia, I think he was experimenting as early as 1903 at the time there was a great deal of interest with Aerial photos.
English cigarettes thats the one, the information requested was names of resistance personnel... for records of course....
Detachment of Messenger Dogs. (Meldehundetruppe ). (From French Military Advisory Mission Bulletin). This detachment is commanded by a lieutenant, who has charge of the pigeon service at the same time. The total personnel is about 70. This detachment at the present time has 26 messenger dogs.
Two men are thus assigned to each dog the man who sends a message and the man receiving it. Except in the case of absolute necessity these men always work with the same dog. These dogs have charge of the liaisons between the command posts of company commanders, battalion command posts in line or as support (K. T. K.or B. T. X.) and regimental command posts. They maintain liaison for 3 and 4 kilometer distances. Men and dogs remain about 10 days in the sector and have 20 days' rest the latter usually spent in training.
Detachment of Carrier Pigeons. (Brieftaubenabteilung) . This section is commanded by the same officer who commands the messenger dog detachment. The personnel includes 1 feldwebel ;5 pigeon attendants (Tauben pfleger) to take care of the pigeons; 5 porters (sometimes more) (Taubentraeger) who carry baskets of pigeons to the various command posts, either in wagons or on their backs. These pigeons maintain liaisons between battalion and division command posts. Each battalion command post has, almost regularly, at least 4 pigeons. Company command posts are rarely provided with pigeons. A movable loft is kept near the divisional command post. This is a wagon with one story slightly raised, harnessed to two horses. It can shelter about 150 pigeons, which is the normal allotment per division. The use of night flying pigeons seems to have been very satisfactory so far.
And talking of Dr. Neubronner, I don't know if he was a member of the Guild of Photochemigraphists of Germany (he jolly-well deserved to be, surely?) but here are the Arms of that august body, recorded by Arthur Charles Fox-Davies of Lincoln's Inn, Barrister-at-Law, in his seminal work, THE BOOK OF PUBLIC ARMS (1915):
Just one of those whimsical little touches ...
Belongs in the Reference section perhaps but the book can be viewed on line or downloaded (45 Mb PDF) - http://www.archive.org/details/bookofpublicarms00foxd for any needing royal, municipal etc. crests and arms of the period.
an interesting picture Steve, wonder what's in the Chianti bottle... Dr. Neubronner's camera is for sale by the way, on auction, bidding starts at just some 12.000 euro. With a wooden or plaster? pigeon, all coming from a Hamburg museum. Other question: how's that camera activated, by the bird itself I guess? Could it make just one picture or more? Well, we have or had Project Pigeon, with the Pelican pigeon operated (three pigeons I think) missile in WW2, and the Orcon project in the 50's, with B.F.Skinner involved.